So, they bus the top 5 winners from our school over to the East side on Friday, and Em seemed to be more excited about getting away from routine and having pizza for lunch than she was about the Spelling Bee. She and Hannah were the only ones from her group competing, so they were kinda bummed about missing out on the giggles back at Hale, but they went. They represented. And they had tales when they returned.
"It's rigged" she says on the ride home. "It's soooo rigged that first place went to a Special Ed kid and second went to an Anger Management kid!" she unloads. I guess SpEd kid's word was "paper" and AngMan had "safari . Not such tough words to win on I guess, compared to Em's "synergism". I'm still not clear on why the different level of words based on your ranking in class, but apparently some knucklehead in the district office feels handicapping (no pun intended) the Spelling Bee somehow levels the playing field.
So, what becomes of these two "winners" now that they go on to compete at the next level? Many of the commentors on Part One asked that question. Okay, so you handicap these kids to let them win in our school district, but what happens when they are faced with honest-to-goodness talented spellers at Regional? Are you truly sparing these "special" kids from pain and humiliation? Nah. Maybe for today they feel good about themselves, but tomorrow I think you'd feel even more embarrassed in front of greater competition. Do they build these kids up for an even greater humiliation? Do you give them the sense that they are truly talented only to have them wiped out in the first round?
And what does that say for the District? Are they proud of who they are sending to represent us in front of other school districts? Are we so consumed with making sure the "underdogs" feel good about themselves that we are willing to sacrifice quality education for the dumbing down of America?
Yes, say School District 130 School Board, Superintendent, and administrators. It is all about catering. Catering to anyone that feels mistreated, ignored, discriminated against, or different. It's about cancelling the dresses and suits that had once been required for the 8th grade dinner dance--it's now "casual" because they don't want anyone to feel uncomfortable. It's about not updating a 20 year-old curriculum because that's the projects everyone "loves" to make year after year. It's about not bringing the lower level kids up to speed--it's more of a slowing the bright kids down so as to not embarrass the others. Sigh.
Em continues on laughingly and tells of the Assistant Superindent giving the "We're all okay" speech. Woodrow, in her Easy Spirit shoes and polyester suit, stands up and gives a big talk on how "we are ALL winners" and Em, being my daughter, proceeds to roll her eyes. When she's finished the kids are all cheering, except for Em, who's hooting out "rigged!" amongst the crowd. Hannah is horrified and starts hushing her.
Em turns to Hannah and says "So, if we are all winners, what does that make the losers?"
"Yeah. I never thought about that!" and the lightbulb of reality goes on in Hannah's head.
"The winners aren't really winners then, are they?" Em says with her 13 year old wisdom.
And so the two of them ride the bus home, giggling about the stupid plastic medal that they were all competing for, happy to be winner-losers, and full from all that pizza that they traveled all the way to the other side of the district for.
There is a butterfly that is known for sitting on heads and shoulders of humans. The "admiral" is named because of it's uncanny preference of sitting on your shoulder, much like an epaulet on the uniform of an Admiral in the armed services. It's kind of funny to watch these guys, flitting around the yard, pausing here and there, waiting for you to sit still long enough for them to cop a feel of your head. It's pure joy to have it happen--you hardly feel anything at all. It's just all the gasps of others who whisper of his arrival that you know that you have been honored. You have to just sit there, silently, trying hard not to jump for joy and scare the poor thing away.











